There's a lot of uncertainty about dates and lineage, especially about Capt. Nicholas Stillwell, as he does not appear in some genealogies.
Nicholas Stillwell (1638, Surrey , England) & Rebecca Bayless (1645, Queens, New York) Elias Stillwell (1663, Gravesend, Kings, NY) % Miss Stanley (aft 1863)-3 John Stillwell (15 Aug 1515 - 12 Aug 1558) m. Joane Shudd in 1538, d. 10 Jan 1560 -2 John Stillwell, Jr. (5 Sep 1539 - 9 Feb 1584, ) m. Jane Parle on 26 May 1562 -1 Nicolas Stillwell (2 Oct 1570 - 13 May 1647), m. Alice Holmes 0 Lt. Nicholas STILLWELL, Jr. b. 1603 d. 1672, m. Ann Van Dyke 1 Capt. Nicholas STILLWELL b. 1638 d. Abt 1715 Rebecca BAYLESS b. 24 Nov 1645 d. Abt 1670 2 Elias STILLWELL b. Abt 1663 d. Bef 30 Nov 1715 Ann Burbank STANLEY b. Aft 1663 d. Y 3 Elias STILLWELL b. Abt 1708 d. 4 Feb 1792 Meriam EDDY b. 29 Jan 1709 d. 19 Oct 1803 4 Elizabeth STILLWELL b. 20 Apr 1732 d. 3 Oct 1804 James Thomas GRAHAM b. Abt 1730 d. 12 Jun 1779 5 Rebecca GRAHAM b. Abt 1757 d. Bef 1786 Joseph PITTMAN b. Abt 1753 d. 11 Jun 1829 6 James PITMAN b. 14 May 1775 d. 12 Feb 1863 Rachel McGREW b. Abt 1770 d. Aft 1860 7 Rebecca PITMAN b. 1798 d. Aft 1870 William M. BENNETT b. 1785-1787 d. 19 Aug 1860 8 Harrison BENNETT b. 22 May 1832 d. 21 Jun 1858 Katherine "Kitty" GRIMES b. 1835 d. 1910 9 William BENNETT Elizabeth HAMMOND 10 Samuel Bennett Hattie Riester 11 Damon Bennett Gloria Wert 12 Cecelia Bennett
Nicholas Stillwell ( - 1672) m. Ann UNKNOWN)
Nicholas Stillwell (1640 - 1715) m. Rebecca Bayles
Elias Stillwell (December 13, 1665 - 1713) m. Ann Burbank Stanley
Elias Stillwell (1708 - February 4, 1792) m. Meriam Eddy
Elizabeth Stillwell (April 20, 1732 - October 3, 1804) m. James Thomas Graham
Rebecca Graham (1757 - 1786) m. Joseph Pittman
James Pittman (May 14, 1776 - February 12, 1863) m. Rachel McGrew
Rebecca Pittman (1797 - ) m. William M Bennett
According to a family tree at familysearch.org, this line traces back to Duncan I, King of Scotland and beyond.
My loving maite I did survive"She was a Scotch woman who was a great doctress, and who judging by her handwriting was a woman of education and culture."
And true my age was great
I lived the years of 95
But here behold my fate.
1 John Neil b. Abt 1600
2 John Neil b. Jun 1626
Jeane Gibsone b. Abt 1630
3 Allison Neil b. May 1658
James Edwards b. Abt 1650
4 Elizabeth Edwards b. Abt 1682 d. Bef 1731
John Eddie, Sr. c. 23 Dec 1680 d. Bef Mar 1751
5 Meriam Eddy b. 29 Jan 1709 d. 19 Oct 1803
Lt. Col. Rev War.
Husband of Elizabeth Stillwell. Son of John Graham.
Son of John Graham and brother of Sarah Graham, married Joseph McGrew
Wife of Joseph Pittman. Daughter of James Graham & Elizabeth Stillwell. Death date is approximate.